Human fatal crash rates on surface streets run 8.4 times higher in Memphis than in Boston, according to new Waymo-backed research examining how location and time of day shape driving risk. The two peer-reviewed studies, both accepted for publication in the journal Traffic Injury Prevention, pair human crash databases with granular traffic-volume data to map when and where people actually drive — addressing a gap in safety comparisons that typically rely on blanket national averages. Researchers used the first study to benchmark fatal crash rates across the top 50 most populous U.S. metro areas, while a companion analysis drilled into hour-by-hour risk in Waymo’s four largest operating hubs. Feng Guo, a Virginia Tech statistics professor and lead data scientist at the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute, said meaningful safety assessment “must be context-specific, accounting for the disparities in risk across different regions, infrastructure types, and times of day.”
Highlights
- Surface streets carry a fatal crash rate 2.3 times higher than freeways across the 50 largest U.S. metro areas.
- Memphis drivers face fatal crash rates 8.4 times higher than Boston drivers on surface streets, illustrating how sharply location alone shifts risk.
- Human crash rates in Waymo’s four-hub study spike 2 to 5 times above average on weekday overnights and 2.5 to 6 times on weekend overnights between midnight and 4 a.m.
- Comparing 127 million autonomous miles to time- and location-matched human benchmarks, Waymo reports 359 fewer injury crashes, with 53% of those avoided crashes falling between 8 p.m. and 3:59 a.m.
Where You Drive Shapes the Fatal Crash Baseline
The first study looked at fatal crash involvement across the top 50 most populous U.S. urban areas and found wide swings by city. On surface streets, human drivers in Memphis were involved in fatal crashes at a rate 8.4 times higher than drivers in Boston — a gap the researchers say makes a single national average misleading for either city, overstating risk in Boston roughly threefold while understating it by the same margin in Memphis.
Road type also mattered: across all 50 regions studied, surface streets carried a fatal crash rate 2.3 times higher than freeways. The finding echoes a pattern from Waymo’s earlier crash-type analysis, which found the company’s vehicles significantly reduced injury crashes involving pedestrians, cyclists, and other vulnerable road users compared with human drivers.
When Crash Risk Spikes Most
The second study extended that location-based mapping to add time of day and day of week across four operational hubs: Maricopa County (Phoenix), San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Travis County (Austin). Overnight driving between midnight and 4 a.m. accounts for just 1.5% of total human mileage, but within that narrow window human crash rates surge to 2 to 5 times the general average on weekdays and 2.5 to 6 times on weekends — risk that traditional crash statistics mask under the sheer volume of safer daytime commuting.
“The data points to a significant increase in crash risk during late-night and weekend hours, when road safety is most unpredictable and impaired driving is most prevalent,” said Jonathan Adkins, chief executive officer of the Governors Highway Safety Association. He added that autonomous technology has “the potential… to intervene when human decision-making is impaired, helping prevent behavior-related crashes and save lives.”
Waymo’s Safety Edge in the Riskiest Hours
As a ride-hailing service, Waymo says its fleet drives proportionally four times more overnight miles than the average human driver — concentrating its exposure in the highest-risk windows the research identifies. Despite that, the company reports lower crash rates across every time window analyzed in the study.
Measured against 127 million autonomous miles and time- and location-matched human benchmarks — regardless of fault — Waymo says its vehicles were involved in 359 fewer crashes with injuries, with 189 of those avoided crashes, or 53%, occurring during the overnight hours between 8 p.m. and 3:59 a.m. The company’s most recent Safety Impact Hub analysis now draws on more than 220 million miles, and Waymo says the findings from this earlier, smaller-scale study remain representative at its current operating scale, which includes recently expanded service to San Francisco International Airport.
Sign up for our weekly emails to stay up to date on the latest news!
